Girls Weekend 2026 New York City Saturday, October 10
Good morning! (Lori’s day to write!) We woke up this morning around 7:30ish and made ourselves a cup of coffee in our single server Keurig machine. After chatting some, I decided to take a shower so I could walk to the cute little coffee place (Milk and Pull) around the corner for a gourmet coffee and to check out the corner market in search of butter and some Rubbermaid or the like containers for our leftovers. We have found ourselves in need of these every year on our trips and we forgot to look for some while at the AMAZING food market yesterday. On my way to the coffee place, I noticed that the beautiful church I passed along the way was open. We had noticed the church our first evening here because of the beautiful stained glass windows we could see from the street. Since the doors were open I decided to step in and take a few photos. Turns out it is a Catholic church named Holy Rosary and I was invited to come in for the mass they would be having this morning. I stated that I just wanted to step inside to look at and take photos of the beautiful stained glass windows. I ended up having a conversation with a couple of sweet ladies who told me that this is the “working people’s church” because back when it was built, working people were not allowed to enter the “rich people’s” church, Our Lady of Victory which is roughly 5 blocks away. It was a very pleasant interaction with these two. I took photos and thanked them for sharing the information and continued on to the coffee shop, where I got my mocha with oat milk. When Kathi cooked the night before she made mention of the fact that we could use some more butter (REAL butter) and we have found that it is always beneficial to have food containers on hand to store our leftovers and we found none in the kitchen. On my way back I stopped at the corner market which is pretty much junk food heaven with only Parkay margarine and no reusable food containers at all. We will have to look these items for elsewhere!
I returned to our home away from home to edit my photos from yesterday’s outing and start today’s journal entry!
Today we have a couple of things on our agenda. First at 2pm we have tickets to see the Old City Hall subway station which is no longer used as a stop but, with tickets, you can get a tour. I have been excited about checking this out because it looks elaborately decorated and beautiful and because it is a unique thing to do here in the city and it takes a bit of effort to get a ticket. Tickets are sold only three times a year and tend to sell out in minutes, so one has to get online the day and the minute they go on sale if one stands a chance of getting a ticket. Prior to doing that, however, one must become a member of the New York Transit Museum, because only members can purchase tickets. If one is lucky enough to get a ticket, THEN one must pass a security check in order to be allowed entry to the restricted site. Kathi and I were both lucky enough to pass the test and were allowed entry. The second item on our itinerary was a history tour titled “Edgar Allan Poe In Greenwich Village”.
We were fortunate enough to have beautiful weather for our tours which made strolling the street of the city very pleasant. We met with our tour guide and the rest of the group in City Hall Park, where our photo ID was checked and we were handed receivers on lanyards along with earphones so that we could easily hear our guide and the stories he had to tell. The tour began with some history of the subway system and the logistics of building such a system. This coincided quite nicely with our tour of the New York Transit museum yesterday where we saw many photos and artifacts showing the construction of the tunnels. What greuling work!
In 1904, New York City’s very first subway ride departed from City Hall Station. Thousands of people showed up. The train was only 4 cars long and the station was a work of art with vaulted tile ceilings, leaded skylights and elegant chandeliers, much of which is still in place today. The platform is curved (which is rare in subway design), following the arc of the street which it sits below. Once the use of the subway increased and more cars were added to the train it became clear that it was no longer feasible to use this platform as a stop because the straight part of the platform can accommodate no more than 4 cars safely. The station was decommissioned in 1945 but the number 6 train still passes through on a regular basis. If you are interested in reading more of the history of the unique and beautiful station you can do so here: https://secretnyc.co/old-city-hall-subway-station-hidden-history/. As an aside, Mayor Mamdani chose to have his inauguration ceremony held here.
Once we were back above ground at the end of our tour, we had to quickly leave the group and find the train that would take us to Greenwich Village for our Edgar Allan Poe tour. This was a delightful 2 hour walking tour of the Village that took us by the many places Poe lived between 1837 and 1846. Our tour guide, Andrea Janes, is VERY knowledgeable regarding Poe and is quite obviously a big fan. We met at 85 West Third Street which is the row house where Poe lived at the height of his career. It is now part of NYU and there is a plaque on the outside of the building that explains that this was once Poe’s residence. We chose this tour because it is close to Poe’s death date of October 7, 1849 and it is only offered in October. Poe finished revising “The Raven” while living here as well as writing “The Cask of Amontillado” and “The Facts in the Case of M Valdemar”. Poe brought his young wife (who was also his first cousin and was 13 at the time of the marriage) here to live with him. Unfortunately, she died of tuberculosis at the age of 24. Her prolonged illness and death provided inspiration for many of Poe’s writings and deeply affected him. The tour included stories of Poe’s doings while living in the Village which included some dalliances with some married women who held literary salons in their homes. The guide spoke of these dalliances as being mostly exchanges of passionate poems and letters but people in literary circles were aware of these goings-on, and they eventually led to Victorian scandals & threatened duels.
The guide was passionate as well as knowledgeable about her subject which made for a very interesting and enjoyable tour. I would highly recommend any of her many history tours, operated through her company Boroughs of the Dead, to anyone visiting New York City who is interested in the darker side of the city’s history. Another aside here; the first time Kathi and I came to NYC together decades ago, we stumbled across a delightful gay piano bar in the Village where we enjoyed the company and sang along with the crowd to show tunes. This tour took us by that establishment, Maria’s Crisis Cafe, which has been a fixture in the Village since the late 1800s and brought back happy memories. We gave a fleeting thought to returning there after the tour, but we were tired and the place was packed, so we decided against it.
By the end of this second walking tour, my arthritic feet were screaming in pain and we were ready to head back “home”. We were also quite hungry and made an impromptu decision to buy pizza slices for dinner as we walked by a pizza place on our way from our final subway stop to our cute, little brownstone. Kathi was feeling the need for a glass of wine, too, so while I went on home, Kathi messaged our airbnb host to ask where she might buy a bottle of wine nearby. She realized that the liquor store was farther away than she wanted to walk and she opted to, instead, buy ice cream from Milk and Fill, the coffee shop where we had gotten our morning coffees the day before. She chose a scoop of pumpkin spice and a scoop of chocolate chunk. YUM!! We settled in to eat our slices and decided to watch a television series, “Blue Ridge”, which would most likely become our nightly watch while on this trip. We watched a couple of episodes, then turned in for the night. Good Night, all.






